Reviews for Still Sal : a Miller family story

Kirkus
Copyright © Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.

Sal Miller’s sense of self is shaken just before the start of first grade. The protagonist ofOh, Sal (2022) confronts new challenges. For one thing, Sal’s younger sister, Poppy, now 2, is sharing what used to beSal’s bedroom with her. And Sal’s high expectations for the first day of school are disappointed when her best friend and next-door neighbor, Griffen, is assigned to a different classroom. Griffen’s teacher, the charmingly named Ms. Flowers, seems pretty perfect. By contrast, in less bubbly Ms. McCormick’s class, Sal’s nametag mistakenly reads “Sally,” and Ms. McCormick’s tour of the school is fairly dull. Sal—bright and full of opinions and interest in the world around her—wears her feelings and hopes close to the surface. Fairly sophisticated language and observations stretch the target audience to include third and fourth graders for whom first grade may be a distant memory (or even, for some, never experienced in person). Henkes’ graceful, easy prose, sharp insights, and impressive ability to convey the way children think shine here. He invites readers to empathize with Sal, feeling her disappointment and annoyance with a world that doesn’t always understand her as well as the satisfaction with small victories that bring her back to herself: getting used to a major haircut and learning to connect with Ms. McCormick. Spot art from Henkes is scattered throughout. Characters’ races and ethnicities aren't mentioned; previous titles cued characters as white. A delightful, understated triumph.(Fiction. 6-10) Copyright © Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.

Back